Ready for Adoption?
Adoption Network Law Center
Adoption Network Law Center
Want to Adopt? Click here.
Click here to be helped in California!
Adoption Network Law Center
Pregnant? Click here.
Adoption Network Law Center
Open Adoption Blog

08/22/07

What Kind Of Family Would DO That?

Posted by : Deb Donatti in Open Adoption Blog at 10:12 pm , 501 words, 216 views  
Categories: Ethics In Adoption


How badly do some people wish to adopt? Would some go so far as to ignore good, ethically sound judgement, just turn a deaf ear to injustices done to biological families in order to accept and keep a child in their home? What kind of family would Do something so cruel and immoral, all in the name of getting what they want (the child)?

Apparently these kind of families are in the major headlines of the news everyday, although often we never hear their names, only those who have been victimized by their poor judgement. Recent news has told us about the case of Allison Quets, who wanted her twins returned just an hour after she had signed for the adoption, while suffering from severe malnourishment, duress, and exhaustion. Then there is the case of young Stephanie Bennett, a minor who was coerced to run away from home in order to get her to turn over her five month old daughter over for adoption purposes. The most recent case, that I personally have blogged about, Gary and Cynthia Stocklaufer, who were trying to legally adopt their infant cousin and had him ruthlessly removed because the court deemed Gary to FAT to adopt. These children all reside with adoptive families now, people who saw what was going on, and for whatever reason chose to ignore the warning signs, and there by become part of the problem.

SPONSOR

I admit all these stories had me really wondering what kind of adoptive family would truly accept a child under such circumstances, and proceed with an adoption? When they hear all the things that would have left most of us knowing something is not kosher, why didn’t they do the right thing? These are some mighty desperate and unethical people in my opinion. Unless they are living in a cave, it would be nearly impossible to ignore the media, and the heart rending stories of the families who have been ripped apart to supply them with their child. Honestly how do they rest easy at night, or ever?

I could not do that, I could not, and yet I still believe in adoption and that is can be a good thing. I believe that people should approach accepting the child they do with care, and with every effort made to ensure a legal and ethical placement. I believe people should really, seriously explore openness in adoption, and what ever they can do to honor and preserve the history of that child. I wonder why all people do not seem to agree. I am confused about how some people could completely ignore how they are playing a part in such a travesty against the tiniest and most innocent among us. At the same time, I am not surprised.

Missouri Man Deemed Too Obese To Adopt - *Update

Outraged? Take Action!

The Birthmom in the Gary Stocklaufer Case

Children Placing Children?

The Stephanie Bennett Saga - What Happens Next?

Sick to my stomach

Myths in Open Adoptions # 2

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
The baby in the Stocklaufer case has now been adopted by another family? Wow.

These cases certainly do get a lot of coverage and provide a rallying point. I just wish there could be as much attention paid to the thousands of ethical adoptions that provide the best possible solution for all. That would be the more balanced picture.
PermalinkPermalink 08/23/07 @ 00:00
Comment from: MamaS [Member] Email
How do people rationalize taking a child in a contested placement? Like this.
Point 1: We are good people and we have been wanting a child for X months or years.
Point 2: The agency that has custody of the child has offered us the child.
Point 3: If we say No, the agency will just choose another set of waiting parents.
Point 4: We are good people and we have been wanting a child for X months or years. Therefore, WE Will Take The Baby.
PermalinkPermalink 08/23/07 @ 00:12
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Sandra, No, in the Stocklaufer case the child is in custody of another, court chosen prospective adoptive couple. I am betting the court has already accepted their petition to adopt,or they would not have placed the baby there. It is my opinion then that the Stocklaufer family could have as little as 5 months to fight this. Adoptions in MO can be final in 6 mons, and the other family has already had the baby for almost one month.
Would YOU take this baby with intent to adopt him, knowing the story of the other family? The other adoptive couple have to be aware, but they have rationalised this to be "ok".
Read MamaS's comment. If all people really have to let themselves consider is points 1-4, then we can all just rationalize away any thoughts about ethics.
Telling about the lack of ethics in some adoptions IS actually providing a more balanced picture. That is why I do not chose to talk about open adoption as all hearts and flowers here (others do enough of that).
I think people should know what openess really involves, to make a fully informed choice for themselves.
Personally I don't think people hear ENOUGH about these type of unethical adoption situations.
The Stocklaufer's is just one case, I am personally aware of other ethical questions in that same court. How many other fat parents have lost their adoptive child in Jackson county already, but we never heard about it? My guess is that the Stocklaufers are not the first, but if enough people become aware, perhaps they could become the last family who has to worry about something like that.
Just my hope anyway.
Sorry to be long-winded. I did not allow myself to think too much about similar situations before, till it hit very close to home.
This could have been ME three years ago.
PermalinkPermalink 08/23/07 @ 13:54
Comment from: mariah [Member] Email
This whole situation makes me ill. As someone (Coley?) pointed out, what happens to the the first mother's decision in this case?

I cannot imagine taking that baby hoping to adopt it. The removal is already being contested, and what about time to meet the court's 'conditions' on the part of Mr. Stocklaufer? Doesn't he have ANY rights? Is his wife fat, too? Why can't she be granted a petition to adopt? I thought the whole point was to keep kids with family members if at all possible. That judge needs to be recalled from office!
PermalinkPermalink 08/23/07 @ 15:33
Comment from: mariah [Member] Email
And besides--do they take biological children away from their fat parents? Or adopted children whose adoptive parents become fat after finalization? I really hope the ACLU or someone can help this family.
PermalinkPermalink 08/23/07 @ 15:34
Comment from: Brittanys1stmom [Member] Email · http://www.birthmombuds.com/showcase_alicia.htm
Mariah, you have made such good points. I totally agree with you. Thanks for speaking out on this Deb. I applaud you.
PermalinkPermalink 08/24/07 @ 02:17
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Brittany, I only hope drawing as much attention as possible will change things. Thanks for your support.
PermalinkPermalink 08/25/07 @ 15:40
Comment from: clareb [Member]
Mama S your logic is really scary.
What happens if someone kidnaps your
child and he is offered for adoption?
This happens all the time in Guatemala,
in Vietnam if you can't pay your
hospital bill and in China if you already
have one child and can't pay the
enormous fine for keeping another.
Someone who only considers your questions
1-4 will be able to justify taking him
because its all about them, not the
child and certainly not about you.
PermalinkPermalink 06/03/08 @ 14:34
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Related Discussions

    AdoptHelp
    Want to Adopt?
    AdoptHelp
    AdoptHelp
    Pregnant?
    click here
    AdoptHelp

    Misc

    Subscribe to Open Adoption Blog

     Enter your email address:
     

     

    Who's Online?

    • Coley S. Email
    • Guest Users: 140