Click here for more information


Open Adoption Blog

06/25/07

Pity? No Thanks

Posted by : Deb Donatti in Open Adoption Blog at 11:24 pm , 625 words, 41 views  
Categories: Adoption Frustration, Society's View


The other day I was reading the personal blog of someone whom I respect and have a great deal of admiration for. This person is a birthparent who has turned much of their life around, despite some unfortunate situations, and has found many wonderful things to share with others as a result. They have made open adoption a working reality for their family, and provided theirs as an example of what can happen, if everyone makes openness work the way it ideally should. The thing is I found myself coming away from my reading feeling upset on this particular occasion.

Part of what was so upsetting for me, was to read the expressed feeling (yet again), that if everyone would just try harder, everyone should have this same level of success as this special family. I wondered if the “everyone” was in fact just adoptive parents, because that is the most common belief in society in general. I understand that adoptive parents are the ones who hold all the ability to follow through, and sadly many do not, but out there are many others like myself, who do and who fail through no fault of our own.

SPONSOR
  Adopt in California

I have heard so many times that adoptive parents just do not put our whole heart into contact, if we did it would always work, right? This is upsetting to me as an adoptive mom, because I know it can work (I have a situation), and I also know that it can fail (I have a situation). If following a set pattern assured success, I believe I would have three successful, open adoptions, but people are different and we all have our unique issues. Despite my own attempts to keep one of our children’s adoption open, right now things have apparently dissolved for the moment.

The other thing that hurt to read was a sort of impression that because some must just not be working hard enough at open adoption we should be subject to the pity of others. We simply do not “get it”, if we did our open adoption would be working. I really wondered why I should be the subject of the pity from anyone though? Really it’s not that I have not educated myself, I have. I also have worked very hard to try make open (very, very open) adoption possible for all my kids, but a relationship takes all parties to make it work well, and I have run into situations that I can not be party too, because they are harmful and negative. That’s not what I wanted, or expected, and frankly I was upset and disappointed.

I guess (*sigh) that I just wish people would not see adoptive parents as the heavy all the time, simply because they don’t really have control over all things in our kids adoptions. I can chose to do everything I can to make ours picture perfect open adoptions, but communication is a two way street and when the other party is unwilling, unable, or just down right belligerent, it’s OK for me to say enough is enough. I know this person was not directing anything in their blog at me personally, but the ideas expressed still stung a bit. When you spend so much time trying to do the right thing by everyone else, I just think that no pity is needed if you find you have tried and failed. I am ok with that, I know did my best.

Openness Is A Two Way Street

Open Adoption - Prepare To Be Unprepared

Birthparents Who Don’t Care?

When You Don’t Let Go Of Adoption Sadness- Part One

When You Don’t Let Go Of Adoption Sadness- Part Two

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
I agree that willingness to "work at it" is not enough. If that were true, I could have made my adoption truly open instead of the limbo it is. Both parties have to understand why they are in an open adoption and what that really means.

I believe that poor matches are the norm and the really good, well-functioning open adoptions are only about 25% of the cases. I think that's because it's the rare person who has the level of sensitivity, patience, foresight, empathy, knowledge, and commitment to make open adoption work.

PermalinkPermalink 06/26/07 @ 05:05
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
I believe that poor matches are the norm

I was wondering what you meant by that? If perhaps my child's birthfamily had been matched with someone (other than us) then they would have been better able to share their part of the commitment? I hope thats not it, because again it makes me feel like the fault in failure is being unfairly laid at my feet alone.
Given what I now know of the family dynamics and personalities, in the case of my child, I don't think they (birthfamily) would have worked it out with anyone. You can have all the empathy, knowledge, and commitment in the world and still not be able to bring that out in the other involved party.
The open adoption community leads adoptive parents to believe if they just do their part, of course birthparents will be so willing to work with you, but as we found out, that is not always the case.
PermalinkPermalink 06/26/07 @ 19:13
Comment from: soblessed [Member] Email
Oh, Deb. So sorry you've had this experience. ((HUG)) It's tough when our expectations are high and our realities are so different. It stinks.

FWIW, Deb, I think you are right. I think there are some cases where open adoption is just not feasible for whatever reason. And, as the custodial parent, that is your call to make. Maybe that's why you get the label (uncooperative) and the judgement (pity).

Deb, you've educated yourself, you've committed to and followed through with as open an adoption as you can and it hasn't worked....through no fault of your own. And you are protecting your children from something harmful and negative. What more can you do?

There will always be a group of people who choose to believe negatively about adoptive parents, no matter how you think, act or conduct yourself. I would ventrure to guess the same holds true for birthparents and adoptees, too.

You will absoloutely never make everyone think well of you on this side of heaven. The important thing is to consider your family and what is in their best interest. Having the "thumbs-up" of others (most of whom have NO IDEA what your situation is) is just gravy.

Chin up, you're doing great!! :)
PermalinkPermalink 06/27/07 @ 19:29
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
soblessed, Thanks for the words of encouragement.
And, as the custodial parent, that is your call to make. Maybe that's why you get the label (uncooperative) and the judgement (pity).

I think you have that right.
PermalinkPermalink 06/27/07 @ 20:06
Comment from: Heather Lowe [Member] Email · http://unplanned-pregnancy.adoptionblogs.com/
No Deb, I definitely didn't mean that as a slam at you. I meant that ideally you, as someone committed to making it work, should have been matched with a birthparent who was equally committed. There are plenty of bparents who seek openness and want to make it succeed. Why couldn't you have been paired with someone from that camp?

(Sorry I didn't see this until now. I hardly ever have time to check responses in my blog mailbox.)
PermalinkPermalink 06/29/07 @ 11:20
Comment from: soblessed [Member] Email
"I meant that ideally you, as someone committed to making it work, should have been matched with a birthparent who was equally committed. There are plenty of bparents who seek openness and want to make it succeed."

good question, Heather, I never thought of that, but maybe it could be part of "The Solution" in helping adoption... :)
PermalinkPermalink 06/30/07 @ 20:57
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Categories

Adopt Help Adopt Help Adopt Help

Misc

Subscribe to Open Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 136