Click here for more information


Open Adoption Blog

11/06/07

Negative: Society's View

Posted by : Coley S. in Open Adoption Blog at 05:08 pm , 426 words, 202 views  
Categories: Society's View
One of the biggest negatives that I have come across with our open adoption has to be society’s view of open adoption.

Society just doesn’t get it. People who do not have a direction connection to adoption (and even some of those that do!) don’t understand how in the world it could be beneficial for an adopted child to know both his birth family and his adoptive family, To begin with, many people don’t understand how a woman could just “give away her child” which would then make understanding open adoption very difficult. But for those who put that thought out of mind and just focus on the open adoption part, there is still a huge lack of understanding.

Much of society doesn’t see how it could benefit a child to know both families and spend time with his or her birth family. Some of society thinks that it might be confusing to have a child spend time with his adoptive mother and his “real” mother. Some of society also wonders how it hard it must be for a birthmother to place her child and then repeatedly see him or her over and over again over the years saying goodbye again and again at the end of each visit. And some of society has the whole “having her cake and eating it too” mindset meaning that they feel that a birthmother participating in an open adoption and seeing her child over the years gets to be included in the fun stuff but gets to miss all the difficult stuff. What they don’t know is all the difficult stuff that birthmothers go through emotionally and personally regarding dealing with open adoption and the grief that comes along with being a birthmother.

SPONSOR

Sure, we (birthmothers) could use these comments, views, and stereotypes of society as the beginning of an educational platform to educate them about open adoption and birthmothers. (And sometimes I do!) But let me tell you from personal experience, dealing with the comments and views of society on a regular basis can be tired and overwhelming. There are times that you just want to be you and not have to constantly be talking or explaining this and that.

Society’s view is definitely what I see as one of the biggest negatives in open adoption.

--
Other Positives and Negatives in my NaBloPoMo Series:
1. Positive: Visits
2. Negative: Hearing Him Call Someone Else Mom
3. Positive: My Relationship with Charlie's Adoptive Parents
4. Negative: Moments Missed
5. Positive: Moments I haven't Missed

Photo credit

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: John [Member] Email
Coley I always enjoy reading your posts. Let me present the 'other' view. Traditionaly, adoption was intended to be a fresh start for the child. This does not mean pretending that there were no birthparents. The child gets to start anew, with a life as normal as it can possibly be. Open adoption is a new way of doing adoption, it is still in the learning and fine tuning stages. The fresh start has a very long history.

Folks who see open adoption as the way to go surely can't imagine how anyone could see the value of a fresh start. Unfortunately, those of us who have adopted using the fresh start are just as amazed that folks would willingly deny the child the much less confilcted and more normal life that comes with that approach. We aren't opposed to contact, we just feel that it should come after 18 when the child is more able to handle this relationship.

All is not lost, I know I am not the only 'fresh starter' who regularly reads your post. We actually can learn. My only intent is to present the other view, that is part of the world of adoption. John
PermalinkPermalink 11/06/07 @ 17:34
Comment from: hslowe [Member] Email
John, actually, openness in adoption (i.e., no secrecy, and sometimes contact with birthfamily) was the norm until the 1920s. Check out a few adoption history books. And open adoption has been going on for at least 25 years now. So it's not so new.

PermalinkPermalink 11/06/07 @ 20:25
Comment from: John [Member] Email
Heather, of course you are right. Before the 20s, psychology was very limited, so follow up couldn't have included the numer of areas looked at since the 50s. Record keeping also tended to be very limited in the earlier era.

You know, one of the problems is definition, what is and what is not open adoption? I would not be comfortable with parent contact before 18. Birth family contact though, in many cases is a no brainer. I think most parents who adopt older kids do visits with sibs who are in the system, or adoptied. Many of our kids have contact with some birth relatives. Is that open adoption? I have always thought it meant child visits with the birthparents.

Obviously, in the right situation, some visitation would be appropriate. I read Jenna and Coley's posts, I am sure those adoptive parents are very pleased with their open adoptions. Keep talkin, we are listening. John
PermalinkPermalink 11/06/07 @ 21:10
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
John,

I understand your point of view and I appreciate your commenting.

I totally understand that society is stuck in that "fresh start" approach to adoption. That's why I'm fine with enlightening them most days, but there are some days I just don't feel like being one of the poster birthmoms for open adoption which is why I consider that one of my personal negatives of open adoption, which is what this post was all about. :)
PermalinkPermalink 11/06/07 @ 21:20
Comment from: roni [Member] Email · http://rondidondi.wordpress.com
Recently I had a conversation with a lady who didn't like the thought of open adoption. She actually told me I probably would have placed PooWee if I never saw him and didn't know with whom or where he was going. She felt open adoption was wrong, because it "hurts" the adoptee to know his bio parents.
I really couldn't believe what I was hearing. I told her my view and hope she took some of what I had to say to heart.
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 08:45
Comment from: Coley S. [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Yes, Roni, so much of society is still in the dark about open adoption! I'm glad you took a few moments to educate her. :)
PermalinkPermalink 11/07/07 @ 10:55
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp

Misc

Subscribe to Open Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • jmgillis
  • rmcnair
  • Guest Users: 159