Click here for more information


Open Adoption Blog

08/26/07

If She Could Undo It All, She Would

Posted by : Deb Donatti in Open Adoption Blog at 11:27 pm , 616 words, 139 views  
Categories: Open About Adoption, Grief/Loss


One of the hardest things about being in an open adoption relationship, can be hearing from your child’s birthmother, that if she could go back, she would have never chosen adoption for her child.

While you might not fault a woman, for later feeling that her decision to place her child was not a good one for her personally, it is also hard not to feel blamed or inadequate if you are the adoptive family in question. It is hard not to feel like the source of the pain and regret.

While I doubt that adoptive parents expect their child’s birthmother to be blissfully happy about placing her child for adoption, we must on some level hope that she will feel some sense of peace with her past decision. Sometimes this knowledge of a birthmother’s regret might feel like we are also being striped of our entitlement to now parent our child. It can come as a shock, especially if time has passed, and contact has been positive to this point.

SPONSOR
http://www.adopthelp.com

It becomes very easy for a birthmother who is experiencing this kind of regret, to perhaps become angry and blaming of the adoptive parents, after all they are the living example of what she has lost, and to whom. They are the parents she chose for her child, because she did not believe she could chose to be that herself for her child.

As adoptive parents you may have done everything ethically and with the best of intentions, but there is no real way to predict how a mother will feel about placing her child months or years down the road. If a situation changes drastically in a mother’s life, she might come to understand how she could have in fact parented her child, and her loss becomes intensified.

Most of us could surely understand the regrets involved, we may also have come to know our child’s first mother as a capable and caring person. But how does it feel, to hear that a mother who once entrusted us with her child to parent as our own, now wishes she had never done so? Even if she shares that her feelings have nothing to do with the adoptive parents themselves, I am sure on some level that they feel some guilt and struggle with the news. I believe that this then makes a difference in the way the adoptive parents may parent the child.

Perhaps this change of heart comes about after the initial “honeymoon” period of an open adoption, or after a birthmother goes on to have another, parented child. Many young mothers who might have felt insecure about their ability to parent their first child, may find that they would have done fine, once they have had the experience of parenting a subsequent baby. Maybe just time and maturity, or real life experience with adoption itself are the catalyst for regret.

If you are in an open adoption, talking about this with your child’s birthmother can hopefully avoid laying blame where it would not be productive in the relationship. Understanding that it is ok for a birthmother to experience this kind of regret, and not passing judgement about it, is important for adoptive parents to do. For birthmothers trying very hard to separate the way they feel about regretting their decision to place their child, from how they feel on a personal level about their child’s adoptive family is equally as important.

Regrets

Regret

Living In The Shadows Of Adoption Loss

More Thoughts on "A Different Kind of Relationship"

For information/instructions on how to subscribe FREE to your favorite AdoptionBlogs, please visit this link.


Photo

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
“Most people hew the battlements of life from compromise, erecting their impregnable keeps from judicious submissions, fabricating their philosophical drawbacks from emotional retractions and scalding marauders in the boiling oil of sour grapes.”

I suspect that on a grand scale what you are writing about is the root of the rift that divides the adoption community.

I'm guessing some would suggest that this is a reason to end adoptions altogether. I'm thinking they would be missing the point.
PermalinkPermalink 08/27/07 @ 00:45
Comment from: Jenna Hatfield [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
While we all know my regret, I have been very concise in stating that it has absolutely, 100% nothing to do with J&D. I think many adoptive parents should remember that unless they acted unethically or coerced the mother into placing, they are not at fault even if the birth parent(s) are making it out to be as such. I'm sure it's hard and uncomfortable and just downright icky. I don't envy the position at all.

Good post, Deb.
PermalinkPermalink 08/27/07 @ 07:54
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Jenna, Your right, but it is worse than hard. Even if a birthmother lets the adoptive family know it is not about them.
Your own experience is a great example of working it out in a positive way. Sometimes though I can see why some families might end an open adoption if this becomes unfair anger and blaming. It is hard to deal with that on a daily basis, and still be an effective parents/birthparents for the child caught in the middle.
I am more than glad that has NOT been your outcome, even though your situation holds some unfair (agency) treatment of you, and some very fair regrets about how you were misled.

Sandra, I think you are right. When people feel powerless about regret gone mad, I am sure looking to kill everything off at the source (good and bad)they believe might fix things. Some of us do know that it is a ton more complex than that.
PermalinkPermalink 08/27/07 @ 11:43
Comment from: soblessed [Member] Email
I really think this is where better counseling and better practice can be so helpful for both birth and adoptive parents. Agencies NEED to tell birthparents about regret, about how a decision that needs to be made NOW could very well be a totally different decision if it just could have occurred at a different time/in different circumstances. They also need to be doing a good job at helping birthmothers explore ALL options, meaning taking a good hard look at the parenting option, in order to avoid an awful kind of regret....in order to avoid the self-recrimination and guilt that comes when a decision was made to make an adoption plan when it didn't need to happen. While not a birthmother, I definitely think the self-recrimination/shame type of guilt is the hardest to deal with....

Agencies also need to do a better job at telling adoptive parents that regret is (my opinion, again) a normal part of loss, which makes it a normal part of adoption. Regret, however, does NOT automatically mean that the adoption is unethical or even unnecessary. They are not mutually inclusive. Maybe that would even help adoptive parents in the daunting task of staying objective when a birthmother expresses regret.



PermalinkPermalink 08/27/07 @ 14:57
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
Want to Adopt?
AdoptHelp
AdoptHelp
Pregnant?
click here
AdoptHelp

Misc

Subscribe to Open Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 87