Click Here to be helped in California!


Pregnant? Click Here
Open Adoption Blog

09/13/07

Adoptive Parents Who Think They “Get It” Probably Don’t

Posted by : Deb Donatti in Open Adoption Blog at 10:31 pm , 605 words, 308 views  
Categories: Spotlight On, Blog/Blogger


I know I have commented before about some fellow adoptive parents, who feel they have the ability to totally understand the birthparent experience, and how much that attitude bugs me. I have been told time and time again, by the few who think they have it all figured out, how some of the rest of us just don’t “get it." As if some adoptive parents could ever really have a handle on what birthparents go through! My own belief is that no way do I know what it feels like to be a birthparent, I barely have a clue, but I do want to listen and learn.

While reading in the blog world the other day I ran across a post by Paragraphein which just confirms my thoughts, that I don’t know half as much as what there may be to know about losing a child and becoming a birthparent. Her post lays bare just the tiniest suggestion of what most birthmoms, even those in very open adoptions, might be feeling about adoption, loss, and how very little the rest of us truly understand it. If this is just the tip of the experience, could those other adoptive parents please just accept with me, that perhaps there is ten times more that we have not even begun to understand?

“But basically? Basically, I’m awfully good at nodding noncomittally, at not rocking the boat, at not causing a stir. At keeping my true and deep feelings private.”

SPONSOR


How can these adoptive parents who are the activists, and the stanch defenders of birthparent outrage and indignation, fully accept and fully align themselves with what they have never fully been privy to though? To me it almost seems like a dangerous assumption that we as adoptive parents could claim full knowledge of how it feels, to be one of those who surrendered their children into our care. We can’t. To me the only thing that is obvious is, that I have a ton of listening yet to do. I may never, ever hear enough to know even the slightest about what the birthparents of my children go through though.

“So the next time you’re tempted to think that you know “the birth mother experience” because your acquaintance at church, your coworker, your friend from high school ten years ago, or even your child’s first mom has said something to you about her own relinquishment…. just remember.
You’re probably not even getting the tip of the iceberg.
And in fact, there’s a good chance even she isn’t aware of the whole iceberg.”

I believe there is a good chance that those adoptive parents who honestly feel they totally “get” the birthparent journey, are not saying that to be hostile or hurtful to others. At least I hope there is not hidden animosity there. My thought is that adoption also hurts them so much, as adoptive parents, on some level. It is so frightening to be in the dark about something so emotionally tied to the essence of what we have built our lives around (adoption and adoption loss). Some may need to convince themselves they have it figured out, as a method to cope.

We adoptive parents have our secrets too. Perhaps we do not want to allow our own frailness and insecurities, created under the pressure of adoption complexities, to become visible to others. Perhaps we don’t want others to sense that we know we really don't get it at all.

Photo

For information/instructions on how to subscribe FREE to your favorite AdoptionBlogs, please visit this link.

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Nicole [Member] Email
Interesting post, Deb.

What I'm contemplating, musing on, is your interpretation of my post.... because you took it farther than I actually intended. Not that I'm upset about that or anything, that's what critical writing is all about, interpreting, finding what the text says that the author might not even be aware of. It's just interesting...

Because I actually DO think some adoptive parents fully "get it." And I am a minority in that belief. I see other first moms say constantly that no matter what, there is just no way an adoptive parent can understand... and I find myself shaking my head.

I DO think adoptive parents CAN understand. Not that they EXPERIENCE it at the same gut-level way we do, but that they can understand. I've seen amoms write words that EXACTLY reflect what I feel and mean. There are a few amoms I trust 100% to write for me, to represent, my own positions on adoption.

I did say that I am more honest online than in real life. And that's the thing... the amoms I think who FULLY "get it" are online amoms, ones who read the words of our blogs, our innermost feelings.

My concern is more that I hear a lot of aparents claim that adoption (relinquishment) can't be so bad, because they know a birth mom in real life, and THAT birth mom is fine with her decision/experience. I guess the point I was trying to make was... what you know from a real-life (LOL) birth mom may not be an accurate reflection of how she truly feels. And also, that our children's aparents tend to be the LAST ones most of us would share all the really difficult stuff with. (Exception seems to be Jenna!)

I know a lot of us are more honest online than IRL... first moms and adoptees, too...

So... not sure I agree with you, but I think your take on my post is interesting, LOL. Thanks for writing about it.
PermalinkPermalink 09/14/07 @ 17:06
Comment from: Nicole [Member] Email
Oh, by way of an example of evidence, to me, of an amom who really "Gets It".... Check out this blog post:

http://goingbacktosquareone.blogspot.com/2007/09/real-life-hard-decisions-part-ii.html

I absolutely, completely believe that she does get it... totally.
PermalinkPermalink 09/14/07 @ 17:07
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Nicole, Thanks for responding. Sorry if I went further with your comments that what you expressed, I certainly did not do that to offend at all.
Of course I read your blog, and I hear a lot of what you say, although I do not always understand or agree.
I guess the extra touch of my own frustration, that I used parts of your blog to highlight, is that a few of these adoptive parents think because of what they understand, that all the rest must not "get" anything. Personally I have had several adoptive parents go off on me, because they feel that I do not "get it", but I think I get about as much as I as an adoptive mom could.
I am no "newbie" to the world of adoption, I have pretty much lived some aspect or another all my life and I have three kids with open adoptions now. I do feel that I “get” many things, but I am not a birthparent. I do not totally understand that experience.
The most interesting thing to me about all of this, is that I often find myself criticized from all sides, but mostly I think because those people do not fully “get” me. Truth be told though the only ones who really need to get me are my husband, my kids and their birthfamilies. The rest of the world will just have to wonder, but they probably will not come close, LOL.

PermalinkPermalink 09/14/07 @ 19:59
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

Categories

Adopt Help Adopt Help Adopt Help

Misc

Subscribe to Open Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • Guest Users: 128