Click here for more information


Open Adoption Blog

06/11/07

Adoption Reform Or Propaganda?

Posted by : Deb Donatti in Open Adoption Blog at 08:46 pm , 570 words, 108 views  
Categories: Ethics In Adoption, Adoption Frustration, Society's View


"Propaganda is the deliberate, systematic attempt to shape perceptions, manipulate cognitions, and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandist." Source: Garth S. Jowett and Victoria O'Donnell, Propaganda And Persuasion, 4th edition, 2006.


I have no doubt that reforms are needed in the world of adoption, to say otherwise would be to blatantly ignore the many flaws of our current system. Scores of other adoptive parents also see the ills of the past era of adoptions, and also some of the current day practices, as woefully in need of dramatic, positive change. Some of the things that I personally support in the way of reform and change include, equal access to adoption records by adult adoptees, and the removal of money and profit from any adoption equation.

Beyond this normal level of concern and reform movement however, is also a world of those who would rather put an end to ALL adoption regardless of how ethically done, or how much it was in the best interest of a child in need. The adoption of children does serve a purpose, no matter how much this purpose often gets lost in the mire. Adoption provides care and stability for many, many children who would not ever know it otherwise. Adoption also provides a compassionate option for many birthparents who chose to place.

SPONSOR


As with anything in life there are both positives and negatives, gains and losses with in the adoption experience. All too often however, there are those who would prefer to cast only a bright light on negatives in order to overshadow those positives, and promote their own particular agenda. In my opinion many of those persons should consider becoming lawyers or politicians because they have such an artful way of carefully wording and stepping around certain details and highlighting only those that help their cause. That cause is to end any form of adoption, however possible. People must become aware of the powerful propaganda that is behind this anti-adoption movement.

Some, who chose to focus only on the negative aspects of adoption, prefer to slant their information to reflect adoption and adoptive parents as anything but positive, anything but good folk by any definition or standard. For those extreme groups they often write a type of “double talk” that can appear to the causal observer to only promote reform in the world of adoption, but upon a closer look it becomes apparent that NO ADOPTION is all that could ever meet such extreme standards. Point this out though, and you will be flooded with an onslaught of what could only be termed as anti-adoption “Propaganda” trying to convince the reader that what was intended was far removed from what was actually said. Do not be persuaded!

For so many of the children in our world, waiting for laws and reforms will mean waiting without a family and a better chance in life. For those children adoption may be the only, best option and it needs to be made as ethical and safe as possible. Those who really, truly desire reform in the world of adoption, understand that adoption CAN be made a positive, loving option for the lives of many children. The key to bringing this out is to promote positive changes IN adoption and not simply changes away FROM adoption.

Trash adoption, sell a book

The Responsibility Of Choices

Adoption Opinions - Off Limits?

Comments, Pingbacks:

Comment from: Sandra Hanks Benoiton [Member] Email · http://international.adoptionblogs.com/
Amen!
PermalinkPermalink 06/11/07 @ 23:31
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
"Point this out though, and you will be flooded with an onslaught of what could only be termed as anti-adoption “Propaganda” trying to convince the reader that what was intended was far removed from what was actually said. Do not be persuaded!"

Could you elaborate on this further? It sounds as though you are convinced that you know what others REALLY mean more than they do themselves. How about an example?

"Those who really, truly desire reform in the world of adoption, understand that adoption CAN be made a positive, loving option for the lives of many children. The key to bringing this out is to promote positive changes IN adoption and not simply changes away FROM adoption."

I completely agree with that statement.
PermalinkPermalink 06/11/07 @ 23:56
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
Jan,
Welcome back from your vacation early!
If you check my links I think it will answer your questions.
Thanks
PermalinkPermalink 06/12/07 @ 08:08
Comment from: Jan Baker [Member] Email · http://birthparents.adoptionblogs.com/
Deb, I haven't left yet - am not leaving till Friday. Will check your links out, though I already know that one of them does not answer my question.
PermalinkPermalink 06/12/07 @ 13:38
Comment from: merrill1277 [Member] Email
"Propaganda is the deliberate, systematic attempt to shape perceptions, manipulate cognitions, and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandist." Source: Garth S. Jowett and Victoria O'Donnell, Propaganda And Persuasion, 4th edition, 2006.

Thank you for providing this definition. It explains in good part how I came to lose my firstborn to adoption, something that went against everything inside of me but was pushed by others who had a stake in it.
PermalinkPermalink 06/14/07 @ 12:05
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
merrill1277 , I am sorry to hear that you made a decision for your firstborn that you now regret.
Maybe you will find my second link above interesting?
http://open.adoptionblogs.com/index.php/weblogs/the-responsibility-of-choices
Thanks for your comment
PermalinkPermalink 06/14/07 @ 16:19
Comment from: merrill1277 [Member] Email


"Of course there are many other birthparents who truly feel that they had no choice concerning adoption at all. Taking any responsibility for something may seem impossible to do when you feel you had no choice."

As one of those birthparents, it's not a matter of "feeling" there was no choice, there was no choice, period.

Taking responsibility for something one didn't choose is more about pleasing others than being honest. That birth parents "take responsibilty" is strongly encouraged by others, and those who do so are praised and considered 'good' birthmothers whether it actually was a choice or not.

"you made a decision for your firstborn that you now regret."

It's extremely presumptuous to project "decisions" "choices" and "responsibilities" onto birthparents in general and people you don't even know in particular. You don't know what kind of choices they had or not, unless they tell you. "Regret" doesn't sit right with me either. It implies guilt. How can someone regret something they had no control over.


"What most of us can do is accept responsibility for how we choose to deal with the outcome of those situations, when we made either ill informed choices, or felt we had no available choice. In the end the ways in which we chose to deal with the outcomes, is how we accept the responsibility for shaping who we are.

This I can agree with. But it doesn't help when people who don't even know me try to define or frame my experience for me. Likewise, I'm sure you wouldn't like it if I tried to define or frame your experience with adoption for you.

PermalinkPermalink 06/14/07 @ 20:06
Comment from: Deb Donatti [Member] Email · http://open.adoptionblogs.com
merrill1277,
I am sorry you feel I am attempting to speak for everyone, if you re-read I feel you will find that is not what I am saying at all.
Some of the things mentioned you feel do not apply to you, but to others they might.
As I said. . .
Beyond this normal level of concern and reform movement however, is also a world of those who would rather put an end to ALL adoption regardless of how ethically done, or how much it was in the best interest of a child in need.

To acknowledge this or not is a personal choice, but many out there are indeed aware of it. As much as we desire certian adoption reforms, we also wish to see the rights of children in need, to find loving homes through adoption, preserved.
This might not be your situation, but as you point out, yours is also not MINE, and you don't know me. I am "framing" or "defining" what many, like myself, have experienced. Many, not everyone.
If this does not apply to some that is to be expected.
Again thanks for your comments
PermalinkPermalink 06/14/07 @ 23:38
Leave a Comment: You need to login to leave comments.:

Login | Register

Login To AdoptionBlogs.com

Search

Sponsors

AdoptHelp
Choose an Option









Pregnant?
click here
AdoptHelp.com

Misc

Subscribe to Open Adoption Blog

 Enter your email address:
 

 

Who's Online?

  • cfjustice Email
  • rmcnair
  • Guest Users: 167